top of page
Search

Reading the room: Renewables need to make the case on Burnham's terms

6 days ago
2 min read
Lindsay McCallum is the Founder and Director of Braedown

Burnham's cost of living test is not a retreat from renewables, but it won't protect them by default. Industry will only get support if they can demonstrate, in terms government already uses, that clean power can bring lower, more stable bills and ease the pressure on the cost of living. But winning the argument is only the first step. It only counts once it shows up in decisions on auctions, grid and investment.


Andy Burnham attends COP31 having made the cost of living the test for energy decisions in the Budget and in announcements expected on clean power auction reform and the 10-year spending plan. Since the Jackdaw approval and the Autumn Budget, coverage increasingly frames the situation as a split within Labour that leans towards a retreat from climate and renewables. The Green Alliance, for example, is suggesting this could be the weakest government on climate in a decade. That reading is premature and not necessarily accurate. The disagreements reflect Labour’s broad coalition competing to fit their causes into a single cost-of-living narrative, and that process is still open. A drift from green power becomes the settled position only if industry treats the direction as fixed and stops making its case.


Burnham has made the cost of living the north star and the framing of his decision-making. To him, this is just reading the room and recognising that when government goes issue by issue, considering backlash and adjusting policy accordingly, the electorate is left unsure of what government stands for.


This contest to be part of Burnham's framing becomes apparent in flashpoint issues, like Rosebank, which become proxies for broader political disagreements around reindustrialisation, local power, and climate change. These flashpoints should be seen as an opportunity to demonstrate that more ambition towards renewables is a decisive part of the government’s own goal of tackling the cost of living. The UK’s reliance on gas leaves us hostage to international gas prices and foreign policy out of our control. Consequently, British households sit near the top of an unenviable league table, with only three countries in the EU paying more for domestic energy. Inserting the path of homegrown, cheap, and abundant renewable energy into this conversation rather than the environmentalist one is how it becomes a durable part of Burnham’s policy and, indeed, of future governments. Again, this is simply reading the room in our framing, not neglecting the very real environmental payoffs of accelerating the energy transition. This strategy also means integrating renewables into rising causes like reindustrialisation or devolution, demonstrating renewables as a path forward to all of these things while highlighting the policy gaps that restrain it today: the grid and storage, to name a few.


The prime minister knows that the status quo is unsustainable. On Monday, NESO's low wind margin warning resulted in the grid yet again leaning on costly peaking gas power stations. The task at hand for industry is to show government and the public that the unavoidable long-term solution is more grid capacity, flexibility, and above all, more certainty on investment. While the narrative is being won, we have to remain vigilant and ambitious on delivery: grid, storage, and investment.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page